The Accountability Trap: When Other Executives Control Your Results

Executives are held accountable for results shaped by decisions across other departments. A RevOps VP, for example, may own forecast accuracy without controlling how Sales and Marketing enter or manage data. Executive job architecture defines decision authority and accountability, reducing delays and clarifying who is responsible for results.

Four pairs of purple isometric cubes on navy, set on a shared baseline. In each pair the left column is taller than the one before, while the right column stays a single cube high throughout.

Fig. 01 — Each reorganization adds a level of responsibility. The authority beside it stays where it was first assigned.

FOR DIRECTORS AND VPs

Your role has grown beyond the authority the company gave you.

You are expected to deliver bigger results, take on more responsibility, and answer for work that crosses several departments. But you may not have the authority to direct the people or make the decisions that determine those results.

This is more than a problem of workload. It is a problem with how companies assign responsibility.

Research suggests that some managers have a reason to keep capable employees in their current roles. In a study of managers at one large German manufacturer, three in four acknowledged holding on to talent. Some employees reported that managers gave them lower performance ratings because they feared losing them. Others said their development was held back so they would stay.

(Ingrid Haegele, “Talent Hoarding in Organizations,” American Economic Review, 2026. Survey of managers at a single firm.)

The result can be an executive who keeps taking on more while the company has little reason to change the role.

But there is another part of this problem that gets less attention: You can be accountable for a business result without controlling the decisions that produce it.

When Accountability Crosses Department Lines

Consider a VP of Revenue Operations responsible for accurate revenue forecasts.

The VP depends on Sales and Marketing leaders to provide reliable information. Sales teams need to enter opportunities correctly. Marketing needs to use agreed definitions. Both groups need to follow the same process.

But what happens when they don't?

The VP can point out missing information, explain why the forecast is unreliable, and ask teams to correct their data. But can the VP require Sales and Marketing leaders to change how they work?

If the answer is no, the company has made the VP responsible for information they cannot control.

The VP is expected to explain the numbers, even though other executives control the decisions and actions that shape them.

The company has created a situation where one executive answers for the results, but several others control what goes into them.

You cannot hold one executive fully responsible for a result when other people control the decisions that determine it.

This is an important part of the Executive Authority Gap™. It is not always about one person having too much work or too little influence. Sometimes the problem is that authority stops at the edge of another department.

The Cost of Being Accountable Without Control

For the executive, this creates a difficult position.

You are expected to explain missed targets, unreliable forecasts, and delays. Yet the decisions needed to correct the problems may belong to people outside your reporting line.

You can spend time chasing information, asking for changes, and trying to get agreement. Even when you see the problem clearly, you may not be able to make it stop.

Over time, this can affect how your work is judged. You may be seen as responsible for results that depend on decisions you were never allowed to make.

It can also affect your next career move. The company may depend on you to keep the current operation working, while your role remains unchanged.

Research on unreasonable work demands points to another cost. In a two-month study of 290 workers, people who saw their tasks as unreasonable were more likely to report resentment toward their employer and irritability later. The researchers did not claim this proved one caused the other.

(Semmer et al., Work & Stress, 2015.)

The company pays a price as well. Decisions take longer. Teams work around problems instead of fixing them. Executives spend time trying to get agreement when the business needs someone with the authority to make the call.

The company may think it has a performance problem. It may actually have a problem with who has the power to make decisions.

Why Influence Is Not Enough

The usual advice is to build stronger relationships, communicate better, and learn to influence people across the business.

Those skills have value. But they do not give you the right to make a decision.

A Sales executive may agree that the data needs to change. A Marketing executive may support a new process. But agreement does not mean either person is required to act.

Research by Burris and colleagues found that ideas were more likely to be put into action when they were brought to people with the authority and resources to act. Ideas brought to peers were less likely to move forward.

The difference matters. Getting someone to agree with you is not the same as having the authority to make the decision.

You can keep asking, explaining, and building support. But if the people controlling the work have no reason to follow your direction, the same problems can continue.

Influence can help move a decision. It cannot replace the authority to make one.

The Role Has to Match the Work

This is where the company needs to look beyond the job description.

If a VP is responsible for a result that depends on several departments, the role needs to account for that. The company must be clear about which decisions the VP can make, which decisions belong to other executives, and how disagreements are resolved.

Without that clarity, the VP can remain accountable for results without having a clear way to deliver them.

This is the purpose of executive job architecture: making sure the role reflects the work the company expects it to carry and the authority needed to do that work.

For the executive, that means a clearer mandate and a stronger basis for discussions about role scope, promotion, and compensation.

For the business, it means fewer decisions caught between departments, clearer ownership, and accountability that matches the power to act.

The goal is not to give one executive control over everything. It is to make sure the right people have the authority to make the decisions they are held responsible for.

Look at the Decisions Behind Your Results

Think about the results you are expected to deliver.

Which other executives control the information, resources, or decisions those results depend on? What happens when they do not follow the process or agree with the changes you need?

Those questions can reveal a gap that a job title or performance review may never show.

If your role has grown but the authority needed to do the job has not been addressed, the answer is not simply to become more persuasive.

The role itself may need to be redefined.

Blumaverick works with executives on this issue through executive job architecture, aligning the work a role carries with the authority and decision rights needed to deliver it.

The Executive Authority Gap Checklist Diagnostic is a starting point for examining where your accountability extends beyond your authority. ➯‍ ‍

About the Author

Patricia Collins

Patricia Collins

Founder & Principal Executive Advisor, Blumaverick·Author
Former IBM VP & Head of Growth Strategy ($60B)·Category-Defining CMO, EVRYTHNG IoT

Advises Directors through C-suite executives carrying responsibility without authority. The cause sits in the job structure, not the person — the Executive Authority Gap™. The Executive Authority Method™ closes it. Executive advisory, not coaching.

blumaverick.io